Alonso's Penalty in Melbourne Sparks Outrage

Alonso’s Penalty in Melbourne Sparks Outrage

27/03/2024

One of Spain’s highest-ranking motorsport officials has criticized the highly controversial penalty imposed on Fernando Alonso in Melbourne.

The FIA believes that George Russell’s heavy crash in the final moments of the Australian GP was due to being “brake-tested” by Alonso – a maneuver considered highly dangerous.

Others, however, have criticized the FIA stewards, including former F1 driver Johnny Herbert, who has had several disputes with the two-time champion Alonso in the past.

“The fact that Herbert himself says it wasn’t Alonso’s fault seems significant to me. It is well known that their personal relationship is not good,” stated Joaquín Verdegay, FIA official and vice-president of the Spanish motorsport federation, the RFEdA, to Soy Motor.

In a rare move, the Aston Martin F1 team principal, Mike Krack, issued a statement to the media, stating that the penalty given to Alonso “while there was no contact with the trailing car was hard to swallow, but we must accept the decision. We did our best, but without new evidence, we are not in a position to request a review (read here).

Verdegay goes further, alleging that “seemingly identical incidents in Formula 1 often receive very unfairly different treatment.”

“Either a penalty is excessively lenient, or another is excessively harsh, as logically, the same event should warrant the same penalty.”

“Personally, I do not like the penalty imposed on Fernando at all. It seems unfair and disproportionate to me. I wonder where the limit is. Is losing 1 percent of speed okay, but 2 percent is excessive?”

Verdegay, who also occasionally serves as a steward in F1, mentioned having witnessed the “worst brake test ever conducted,” involving Ralf Schumacher and Jacques Villeneuve in Melbourne in 2001.

“It ended in the worst possible way, with the death of a trackside marshal, who was hit by a wheel. A brake test can be fatal, and what happened to Alonso was not a brake test.”

Alonso’s Penalty in Melbourne Sparks Outrage. Alonso’s Penalty in Melbourne Sparks Outrage

F1 Standings 2025
F1 Standings 2025
#
Driver
Points
1
Driver Flag
Max Verstappen
Red Bull
0
2
Driver Flag
Lando Norris
McLaren
0
3
Driver Flag
Charles Leclerc
Ferrari
0
4
Driver Flag
Oscar Piastri
McLaren
0
5
Driver Flag
Carlos Sainz
Williams
0
6
Driver Flag
George Russell
Mercedes
0
#
Team
Points
1
McLaren
Norris & Piastri
0
2
Ferrari
Leclerc & Hamilton
0
3
Red Bull
Verstappen & Lawson
0
4
Mercedes
Russell & Antonelli
0
5
Aston Martin
Alonso & Stroll
0
6
Alpine
Gasly & Doohan
0
F1 Calendar 2025
F1 CALENDAR 2025
Race Date
Australia Flag
Australian
Albert Park
16 Mar
China Flag
Chinese
Shanghai International
23 Mar
Japan Flag
Japanese
Suzuka Circuit
6 Apr
Bahrain Flag
Bahrain
Bahrain International
13 Apr
Saudi Arabia Flag
Saudi Arabian
Jeddah Street
20 Apr
FULL CALENDAR
Race Center

Race Center

Australian flag
Australian GP
13 Mar - 16 Mar
Your time Local time
FP1 13 MAR 15:30
FP2 13 MAR 19:00
FP3 14 MAR 15:30
QU 14 MAR 19:00
RACE 15 MAR 18:00
Go toTop